|  | | | Customer Reviews: | | | Average Customer Review: ( 5 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 13 found the following review helpful:
 Poor quality knockoff May 10, 2010
By X. Sorin
The bench arrived damaged with a ding in one corner and a broken piece in the opposite corner. I can write that up to shipping damage, however the overall finish and assembly quality of the product is extremely poor. The material quality seems fine, but absolutely no care was taken in the assembly. I like this style of bench, and after this experience will probably pay the extra money for the real deal.
6 of 7 found the following review helpful:
Nelson knock-off Nov 07, 2010
By kishu
very sketchy rendition of the original Nelson bench. poor quality wood, bad paint job on the legs. not worth bothering with.
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
 Minor imperfections, do not really matter in the big picture. Good value! Mar 05, 2012
By Yanninski
First off, I'm supremely picky about wood surfaces. This item is a knock off of a great bench and as such, there are many imperfections, wood filler, etc. It's also not made of maple, as the original, so the wood has many discolorations as compared to the real George Nelson item.
The interesting thing is, the imperfections are hardly noticeable under normal lighting! Only when looking at a certain angle with a bright light and up close, will you notice the wood filler.
I took a chance to have a great bench for $200 shipped. It's a fantastic design, a work of art, but ultimately in our entrance, it's just a sitting bench.
So... I thought I would be able to deal with some imperfections. To my surprise, they are hardly noticeable under normal circumstances. I've uploaded 10+ pictures from all sorts of angles to highlight these. Very happy !
I also wanted a less deep bench (18.5" is too much for our entrance and 14" is just perfect) I am happy to report the bench was moddable to suit and still maintains a solid structure. (see pictures for final modded bench)
The wood does have more grain and color variation than I would like, but I would not have paid $450 to have a perfect maple bench with super perfect wood. And $799 for the original was out of the question. Keep in mind that most of these benches can be found for $200-$360 online, I have a sneaking suspicion they are all from the same factory. I'm pretty sure anything under $400 will be this exact same bench with a different name so be careful if you get an more expensive clone variant...
So in summary, for $200, it's great value. I hope the pictures are of some value to someone looking to get into an affordable version of the George Nelson Classic.
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
you get what you pay for Jan 14, 2012
By Rebeka A Hammer
received this as a gift, been wanting one of these for some time. The finish on the legs is good, but the wood quality and finish on the seat is a bit sketchy. for one, coming out of the packaging, there was a fair amount of dust. the wood quality is ok, but there are some sizable knots in the wood, which is a bit annoying. the finish is fairly good throughout, but there are patches that are rough or simply without any urethane. the construction quality is by far the sketchiest. there are exposed finish nail heads on the sides and below, and as if that weren't bad, the joints are cut short and the gaps filled with a wood filler of some kind. it looks good from several feet away, but get within arms distance and it beceomes obvious that its a knock off. its about what you'd expect, but still a little disappointing.
Exceptional Value and Great Look Feb 07, 2012
By Stefan
This item is an exceptional value and looks as good as expected.
There is many different vendors to pick this particular bench from. So the decision to buy this one wasn't the easiest. I'm very happy I picked this one for its low price and great quality.
|
| | |
